Illustration of a winding road, with contract negotiation pitfalls along the way for surgeons
Illustration of a winding road, with contract negotiation pitfalls along the way for surgeons
Illustration of a winding road, with contract negotiation pitfalls along the way for surgeons

Surgeon Contract Regrets: Top 8 Pitfalls and How to Navigate Them

Learn the top 8 pitfalls in surgeon contract negotiations and how to avoid them. Gain insights and strategies to secure a contract that supports your patient care and well-being.

By: Chuck Kable, JD

Published: May 16, 2024

📂 Legal Education

Written for:

✅ Early Career Physicians

✅ Mid Career Physicians

✅ Established Professionals

Congratulations on reaching the pinnacle of your career as a surgeon! While securing your dream position is cause for celebration, it's crucial to approach contract negotiations with caution and foresight.

Here, we delve into the top eight regrets often encountered by surgeons in contract negotiations, along with detailed strategies to deftly sidestep them:

OR Scheduling Scramble

  • Regret: Accepting rigid OR scheduling terms can lead to frustration and operational inefficiencies, as it becomes challenging to secure adequate time for complex surgeries.

  • Dodge It: Conduct thorough research on average OR availability at the facility and within your specialty. Armed with this data, negotiate for flexible scheduling arrangements that align with your case volume and the complexity of procedures you perform. Advocate for guaranteed OR time blocks to ensure seamless workflow and optimal patient care.

Call Coverage Burnout

  • Regret: Agreeing to an inequitable call schedule without appropriate compensation can result in burnout, compromising both personal well-being and patient care quality.

  • Dodge It: Prioritize fair call distribution among colleagues and research regional compensation standards for on-call duties. During negotiations, advocate for compensation packages that accurately reflect the demands of being on call, including financial compensation, time off in lieu, and support for backup coverage. Emphasize the importance of a balanced work-life to maintain peak performance and job satisfaction.

Financial Hit from Weak Liability Protection

  • Regret: Settling for inadequate malpractice insurance coverage leaves you vulnerable to significant financial liabilities in the event of legal claims or lawsuits.

  • Dodge It: Take a proactive stance on insurance matters by thoroughly reviewing the terms of malpractice coverage offered in the contract. Prioritize policies that provide comprehensive protection, including tail coverage to address claims made after the termination of your employment. Negotiate for robust indemnification clauses to safeguard your personal assets and professional reputation against unforeseen legal challenges.

Frustration with Unclear Scope of Practice

  • Regret: Unclear or restrictive language regarding your scope of practice in the contract can impede your ability to utilize your full range of skills and expertise.

  • Dodge It: Clearly articulate your qualifications, certifications, and procedural competencies during negotiations. Advocate for language in the contract that reflects the breadth of your training and experience, allowing for flexibility in adapting to evolving patient needs and advancing innovative medical technologies. Seek provisions for ongoing professional development and credentialing opportunities to expand your scope of practice over time.

Missed Opportunities with Quality Metrics

  • Regret: Accepting generic or impractical quality metrics may incentivize suboptimal clinical practices and detract from patient-centered care.

  • Dodge It: Collaborate with institutional stakeholders to define meaningful and achievable quality metrics tailored to your specialty and patient population. Propose outcome-based indicators that prioritize patient safety, clinical effectiveness, and care outcomes. Negotiate incentive structures that reward adherence to evidence-based practices and continuous quality improvement initiatives, fostering a culture of excellence within the healthcare organization.

Stagnation from Neglecting Research

  • Regret: Overlooking opportunities for research support and academic engagement in the contract negotiation phase may hinder professional growth and limit contributions to scientific advancement.

  • Dodge It: Advocate for provisions that recognize and support your scholarly pursuits, including protected time and resources for research activities. Highlight the alignment of your research interests with institutional goals and patient care priorities. Negotiate access to research infrastructure, funding opportunities, and collaborative partnerships with academic institutions to maximize your impact and enhance the reputation of the organization.

Falling Behind in Technology

  • Regret: Failure to secure access to state-of-the-art surgical technologies and training resources can impede clinical innovation and compromise patient outcomes.

  • Dodge It: Conduct a comprehensive assessment of the facility's technological capabilities and equipment inventory. Identify specific equipment needs and training requirements relevant to your practice. During negotiations, advocate for budget allocations and institutional commitments to invest in the latest surgical technologies, ensuring that you have access to the tools necessary to deliver optimal care. Negotiate for ongoing professional development opportunities, including training programs and certification courses, to enhance your proficiency and stay abreast of emerging technologies in your field.

Career Trap of a Restrictive Non-Compete

  • Regret: Agreeing to overly restrictive non-compete clauses can limit career mobility and hinder professional advancement opportunities.

  • Dodge It: Scrutinize non-compete provisions in the contract with careful attention to geographic scope, duration, and enforceability. Negotiate for reasonable limitations that balance the employer's legitimate interests with your career aspirations and professional autonomy. Consider including provisions for buyout options or release clauses to mitigate the impact of restrictive covenants in case of unforeseen career transitions. Prioritize contractual terms that afford you the flexibility to pursue new opportunities and elevate your career trajectory while honoring your contractual obligations and professional ethics.

Essential Considerations for a Comprehensive Surgeon Contract

While the eight pitfalls previously discussed are crucial to avoid, a successful surgeon contract negotiation encompasses a broader scope. Here are additional key considerations to ensure your agreement fosters a fulfilling career and optimal patient care:

Continuing Medical Education (CME) and Professional Development:

  • Regret: Failing to secure support for ongoing education can hinder staying current with advancements in your field.

  • Dodge It: Negotiate for dedicated time off and financial aid for conferences, workshops, and CME relevant to your specialty. This ensures you can maintain your expertise and provide cutting-edge care for your patients.

Workload Management and Patient Volume:

  • Regret: Unclear expectations around patient volume can lead to burnout and compromised care.

  • Dodge It: Discuss patient load expectations and negotiate manageable caseloads to ensure thorough and compassionate care. Advocate for provisions that prioritize patient safety, including adequate staffing and support resources. A balanced workload allows you to deliver exceptional care without sacrificing your well-being.

Contract Renewal and Termination Clauses:

  • Regret: Overlooking these clauses can leave you vulnerable to unexpected changes.

  • Dodge It: Clarify terms related to contract renewal, termination, and notice periods. Negotiate clear criteria for contract renewal, performance evaluations, and exit strategies to protect your interests. This provides security and transparency throughout the duration of your employment.

Health and Wellness Benefits:

  • Regret: Undervaluing health and wellness benefits can impact your overall well-being.

  • Dodge It: Advocate for competitive health insurance coverage, including medical, dental, vision, and mental health services. Negotiate for wellness benefits to support your physical and emotional health. Prioritizing your well-being allows you to provide optimal care for your patients.

Research Support and Funding:

  • Regret: Limited research support can hinder your ability to contribute to scientific discovery.

  • Dodge It (and Advocate): Negotiate for dedicated research funding, grants, and administrative support. Seek institutional commitments to resources for conducting high-quality research. Additionally, consider advocating for broader institutional policies that promote research collaboration and grant opportunities for surgeons.

Community Engagement and Outreach Opportunities:

  • Regret: Overlooking community engagement can hinder your ability to build connections and give back to the community.

  • Dodge It (and Advocate): Advocate for support and resources to participate in community health initiatives, volunteer programs, and educational outreach activities. Negotiate for opportunities to collaborate with local organizations to promote health awareness. Surgeon involvement in community outreach not only benefits the community but also fosters positive relationships and professional recognition.

By considering these additional elements and strategically negotiating your contract, you can secure an agreement that empowers you to provide exceptional patient care, fosters your professional growth, and ensures your well-being throughout your rewarding career in surgery.

Ready to take the next step? From Resident to Practicing Physician: Understanding Employment Contracts

With Chuck Kable, JD 🟢

1. Book Your Session

2. Unpack Employment Contracts

3. Secure Favorable Contract Terms

Choose a Time 🚀

Mastering Your First Employment Agreement: Tailored for newly graduated doctors about to sign their first employment contracts, emphasizing understanding over negotiation.

As you transition from medical school and residency to your first position as a practicing physician, navigating employment contracts is crucial. This session delves into the essentials of employment agreements, focusing on clauses such as non-compete, compensation structures, and malpractice insurance implications. Equip yourself with the knowledge to take control of your career.  Learn not just what your contract means, but how to manage it and your new employer to set yourself up for maximum flexibility with minimum hassle.

Disclaimer: This educational session provides general information on employment contracts in healthcare and is not intended to substitute for professional legal advice. No attorney-client relationship will be created by attending this session. Consult a licensed attorney for advice on specific legal issues.

Read more by Chuck Kable, JD

Stay In The Loop

Join 1300+ physicians who receive our monthly newsletter and stay up to date on our community events, resources, and tools.